Reading - May 2025

Wild Man Creek by Robyn Carr (2011)

There's obviously a formula to the Virgin River books, but Robyn Carr does a good job of varying the principal characters and keeps it from feeling too repetitive. I wish the heroine's ex had been given more of a comeuppance but that wasn't the main point of the story.

Manwatching by Desmond Morris (1977)

I remember this book being in the school library, but other than occasionally looking at the pictures of naked women (hey, I was 13 and we didn't have the internet), I didn't read it. However, I found it a couple of years ago in a charity shop and was curious. There's lots of interest, but what I find most fascinating is completely how it betrays the time in which it was written. Morris goes for a scientific, detached tone but more often only achieves patronising, and overall it couldn't be clearer that this is a book anchored in the male- and white-centric attitudes of the seventies. The whole section on sport only discusses and pictures men, while the section on aesthetic behaviour has photos of women in swimsuits. I'm no anthropologist but it seems obvious that many of the conclusions here mistake superficial and specific western social customs for underlying human "truths". Still, at the very least it's interesting to see how things have changed in the last forty years. (note: the edition I read is the original; the latest is called Peoplewatching and given the change in title, I really hope it's been updated to remove the more egregiously sexist content.)

Harvest Moon by Robyn Carr (2011)

A bit more depth than some of these books, with a troubled teenage daughter complicating the core relationship - but of course, she comes round in the end! At one point I was really caught up in it.

Thief of Time by Terry Pratchett (2001)

More than most Discworld books, this leaves me feeling like there's something I'm missing here that I'm just not well-read enough to understand. But reading the initial quote from Terry Pratchett at the start of the Annotated Pratchett file (link above) makes me think perhaps not. Anyway, the usual Discworld frenetic-ness abounds, although perhaps this one is a bit more meta-physical than usual. Eminently readable and as always, you can't fault the level of imagination that's gone into it.

Listen by Michal Faber (2023)

A hugely enjoyable discussion about why we listen to and enjoy music, from a  sociological perspective rather than a physiological one. If that sounds a bit dry, well, it isn't. Although it's clearly conceived as a complete work, it is effectively structured as a collection of connected essays on related topics. That can make it a little bitty, but I didn't mind as the writing was interesting. If, like me, you love music but (crucially) also tie your identity to some extent to that love of music, then there's lots to think about here. Some of it resonated with opinions I already had, some was a useful new perspective, but all was entertaining. Highly recommended.

Hidden Summit by Robyn Carr (2011)

Book number 15 in the Virgin River series! Getting towards the end now, I think. A pretty straightforward plot, but with some good drama going on too. Ends a bit suddenly though.

Piranesi by Susanna Clarke (2020)

This was recommended to me by B - possibly almost a year ago - and I put it off for ages because I'm not really a fan of fantasy. But it's nicely compact (Susanna Clarke's Jonathan Strange & Mr Norrell is off-puttingly thick) and now I have more time, I felt I owed it to him to give it a go. And I'm pleased I did - it was very readable and I polished it off in an afternoon, so keen was I to learn what it was all about. But even though I really enjoyed it, I'm a bit disappointed. For most of the book, I assumed that the other world described would turn out to be really this world, but seen from a completely different point of view. However, it seems that the other world is, in fact, just another world (like Narnia, to which there are several references). OK, so far, so fantasy. But I do prefer my stories to be rooted in some kind of reality, so this, in some respects, for me, is a less imaginative option. But that's not to take away from the quality of the writing and I liked the slight element of mystery that was gradually unravelled.

Skallagrigg by William Horwood (1987)

I've owned this book since the early 90s (on the recommendation of a friend who wasn't known for reading much) and probably not read it since then. But it's survived various purges of books over thirty years because I remembered it being worth it, and I wasn't wrong. There's a lot going on and much that is very moving, even if it is a borderline mawkish at times (albeit one could say, with justification). A unique story.

Kilt Trip by Alexandra Kiley (2024)

Chosen fairly at random in the library on the basis of an amusing title and a promising premise (although I wouldn't have described this as an "enemies to lovers" romance like the cover says). Some of the relationship obstacles feel a bit forced and our hero is waaayyy to good to be true, but this doesn't stop me willing them to sort everything out.

Nothing Is Real by David Hepworth (2018)

Second time of reading (I saw it in the library and just fancied it - completely failing to remember that I actually own a copy) and I enjoyed it a bit more this time, I think. Hepworth's slightly staccato style is still a little jarring on paper but he knows what he's talking about, and if a few of the collected pieces here are a bit shorter than I'd like, well, never mind. Still waiting for a volume two though.

Showstopper by Peter Lovesey (2023)

An enjoyable murder mystery in the classic Christie mode. It's taken me a year since the first Peter Diamond book I read to get to this one, but I'll find more soon.